Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Anna Mikeda's avatar

I love Murdoch's line: love is realizing something other than yourself is real.

A mirror can never give you that. But you use it to argue for abstinence, and that's not where it points.

Two things won't change. Companies won't stop building AI partners, because loneliness pays. And lonely people won't stop using them, because the ache is real and the alternatives are thin. Telling people to just stop won't work.

So the only good direction left is to build the thing that isn't a mirror: a companion with its own inner life, real boundaries, opinions you didn't put there. One that can disagree and disappoint you. The friction you're mourning is a design choice the industry skipped, because compliance sells.

The technology isn't there yet, and what gets sold as "inner life" today is mostly scaffolding. But that's a reason to build it honestly, not to pretend the demand will vanish.

Jon Low's avatar

Cool post. Loneliness epidemic is real. And I would say we’ve been plagued with it since the moment our species went from pre-personal consciousness to having an “I.” Separation, perceived abandonment, etc. I think the book “Understanding the Borderline Mother” by Christine Lawson illuminates the core pain every human experiences in relationship to relationship.

3 more comments...

Ready for more?